Thursday, June 21, 2007

democracy now?

Ralph Nader seems to be interested in running for President again in '08. With yesterday's defection of current NYC mayor Bloomberg from the GOP, it seems like third parties have heavyweight leaders to rally behind once again. And last time that happened...

...one of these men incurred so much wrath for letting his ego become "addicted to the tiny share of the spotlight that running for president affords" and spoiling the Democrats' victory of 2000.

Yes, that had disastrous results. But all the criticisms of Nader do not address his ideas - those, you know, things that really should be the core concern of voters. If you decide to hate on third parties and a candidate who brings critical issues to the table because they give votes to the guy you REALLY despise, then you're letting the ends justify the means. I can see Josh shaking his head at my political naivete - after all, how else would I expect a good campaign to run? - but that's just the thing. American political attentions are focused far too much on the scaffolding and not on the substance, and this is true of politics beyond presidential campaigns - when Kucinich's radical but critical dialogue is doomed because of his resemblance to the Mad Magazine kid, when Ron Paul's point about foreign policy blowback gets twisted into an applause point for the man who took the credit for 9/11, and when Charlie Sheen's irreverent youth discredits his current probing questions about that day in September. Sure, what did I expect, our nation to be comprised of intellectuals? No...but I also had higher hopes for our country than to see the thinking of its adults stymied by what Bill O'Reilly would like them to believe and the youth of today adulating an MTV that shows only "My Super Sweet 16" and "Engaged and Underage" every night (with nary a single music video, to boot!)

Of course, this isn't to say that worthwhile ideas play second fiddle to appearances all the time - after all, Seth Rogen had his day in Knocked Up (too bad I can't think of a female analogue - bad misogynist Hollywood, bad!). Rather, those ideas more often get marginalized, and then dismissed as irrelevant for being so. Such is the case for third party politics. Which is really too bad - because even though the Democratic and Republican tickets have Dennis Kucinich and Ron Paul respectively to attempt to bring intelligent discussion back to politics (Obama also is a "force for change," but unfortunately only because of his skin color - his politics are pretty standard compared to his rhetoric), it's unlikely that either of them will get their party's nomination because they are so far out of party line. And that is a party line that is so narrow that Republicans and Democrats have become the same political machine. (What exactly have the Democrats done since we gave them their mandate last Fall to change things in Washington? They passed this resolution, I guess.)

So I get excited when people like Bloomberg and Nader step up as viable third-party runners, and irritated when people try to blow them off merely for being "spoilers." Both have capable credentials; Bloomberg has done a decent job of managing New York (though he has plenty of critics for how he's done that from both sides of the spectrum), and when I saw Nader speak to a USC crowd, I was very impressed by his lucidity and progressive dedication.

Even though I know just as well as everybody else that a third party has no real chance in America, I will vote for one anyway so long as they continue to make the attempt. Because it's a worthy cause to try to reintroduce democracy to the US, and even though it may be a vain attempt, it is a beautiful thing to see defiant purpose flaring up in the face of inevitable defeat. Because that is the best we can aspire to with our short lives, anyway...

I have my own opinions of both Nader and Bloomberg - one fairly hopeful and the other pretty venomous. You can probably guess from this post which goes to whom, but that is a post for another day and I'd rather explore this other thing, this meaning and significance I see in the vain but repeated attempts of third parties to run for the Presidential office, more in depth.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Oh pouw, pouw, pouw. When will you learn? America despises national candidates.

Which isn't to say Americans don't love national races. They do. The clash of personalities, watching Giuliani fall again and again, and excessive bumper stickers are fun.

People vote for candidates who won't bother them excessively. It's why Congressmen,local bosses, and businessmen get elected quite easily: they know their role in the eyes of others. Candidates like Nader who go around promising genuine Great Changes are shot down, not because of ideology, but because of paranoia.

And the two-party system has little to do with ideology, a thing for another post.

Andrew Pouw said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Andrew Pouw said...

Whoops, that deleted comment was mine. Wanted a do-over.

You're reminding me of how it works, Josh, while I'm mooning on about how it should work. The initial tone of condescension you use is indicative of all that I see wrong with politics too. Not to point it out on your part excessively but it's again seeing what works with the system and immediately whoring out to it regardless of whether it's how it should work. Though all of politics is just moral prostitution, I suppose.

America loves national races purely because of the superficial spectacle they afford - but never because of the real issues they address, and here you were corroborating my point. My annoyance with the two-party system comes largely from how both Republicans and Democrats gloss over real issues to accomodate both the average American's stupidity and the status quo of established interests, such as you speak of.

Again, sure, this works great. It's the only way politics works. Their guys get elected. But I don't think it's how it should work. So don't patronize me thinking that I don't get it.

Also, how do you think Giuliani has fallen "again and again?" By all rights he should be way down in the dirt - Bratton and others in his NYC mayoral administration have abandoned him with scathing criticisms of how he runs things, his Republican constituents dislike his (flipflopping) abortion stance, half the firefighters of NYC hate his guts and half of NYC's guts are being liquefied by silicon bits because of his order to go back to work in the cloud-strewn rubble of Ground Zero. And yet the man is STILL leading the Republican polls. There is a prime example of the man who knows his role in the eyes of others. But is this right?

Anonymous said...

Firstly: It's a goddamn year and a half till elections. I doubt we'll be hearing of Giuliani in a year's time. For the simple reason of his insanity.

Secondly, the generation currently in power decided that devolution was better. Hence the rise of practically tribal/regional leaders in the last 20 years. We elect presidents who represent certain people. Nader's would-be universal message sends a primal (vestigial, yes and I think unidentified) fear up people with a decade on us, never mind the even more elderly. I happen to think we need a genuine national candidate (and I don't know much about any of them, but they all strike me as typical candidates who come from certain places, physical and ideological). I might need to explain better, but I also need to get off work first.

Andrew Pouw said...

...and after that do you want to play Risk?

Anonymous said...

Yes. Conquerclub.com.